Yes, don't stretch it. Using

In reply to Baskerville MT, Italic:

Yes, don't stretch it. Using another font is a much better compromise; ideally you would find something that says to German readers what Baskerville says to English readers (assuming Baskerville was originally a good choice).

Pablo, I think your project is a great opportunity to reduce the confusion of calling the Fry's cut "Baskerville".

hhp