In reply to My 1st font - WIP - Astor:
Hi Gorgoyle,
I'm no expert, also currently working on my first effort at a typeface :)
My first impression is that there are some unexpected widths in the uppercase, see /R/S/T/U. What sort of grid did you use?
The lowercase feels more consistent, although the bottom right corner of the bowl of the /e is bugging me, and I think should be square.
I can see that you have carried the same corner radius from /D into the /E, but to me it feels like this has reduced its optical width slightly too much.
Agreed the 2 and 5 need work.
Good luck with it - I realise how much stamina is required in this process!